Metformin vs Rybelsus for diabetes: A complete guide

Key points

• Both metformin and Rybelsus lower blood sugar levels, but they work in different ways
• Metformin is available as a generic (more affordable), while Rybelsus is only available as a branded drug and is more expensive
• Your doctor will choose the best diabetes medication based on your blood sugar, weight, complications, insurance coverage, and treatment response

Metformin has been the go-to diabetes medication for decades. Now, there's Rybelsus, the first oral GLP-1 medication that's changing how doctors approach blood sugar management.

With one costing pennies per dose and the other approaching $1,000 monthly, the choice between these medications involves more than just price.

This guide examines what matters when comparing these two different diabetes medications.

How do Rybelsus and Metformin work?

How Rybelsus works

Rybelsus is a glucagon-like peptide-1 (GLP-1) receptor agonist that mimics a natural hormone your body produces. It is a pill form of semaglutide and is FDA-approved to treat type 2 diabetes. Other popular semaglutide drugs are Ozempic and Wegovy.

Rybelsus works in 4 ways:

• Reduces hunger levels
• Your pancreas releases more insulin after a meal to prevent blood sugar spikes
• The liver stops releasing extra sugar into your bloodstream
• Food moves more slowly through your stomach, helping you feel full for a longer time

How metformin works

Metformin, a popular drug for blood sugar control and type 2 diabetes management, takes a different approach from semaglutide.

• Metformin reduces the amount of sugar your liver produces. The liver normally releases stored sugar (known as glycogen) into your bloodstream, but metformin dials this back.
• It helps your body become more sensitive to insulin. So, your existing insulin works better.
• It reduces how much sugar your intestines absorb from food. This helps prevent post-meal blood sugar spikes.

"Metformin is typically the first medication your healthcare provider will prescribe for type 2 diabetes. If you need additional blood sugar control, Rybelsus may be added to your treatment plan. Your healthcare provider will make this decision based on your unique health condition and how well your blood sugar responds to initial treatment," explains Gia Eapen, MD.

Metformin vs Rybelsus: Dosage and administration

How is Rybelsus administered?

Rybelsus is a pill taken once daily, first thing in the morning, with no more than 4 oz of plain water. It is recommended to wait at least 30 minutes before eating or drinking anything else . This timing is recommended to optimize absorption.

Typically, the starting dose is 3 mg for 30 days to help your body adjust. After that, your doctor may increase the dose to 7 mg. If needed after another month, you might be moved up to 14 mg.

How is metformin administered?

Metformin comes in two forms: immediate-release (IR) and extended-release (ER). The IR version is typically taken twice daily with food. The ER version is usually taken once daily with your evening meal.

Food helps reduce stomach upset, a common side effect. The ER version releases medication slowly, which may mean fewer digestive issues. Doctors typically start with 500 mg and gradually increase by 500 mg or 850 mg increments weekly until blood sugar is controlled. The maximum dose is 2,550 mg daily.

Metformin vs Rybelsus: Which one is better for blood sugar control?

"Both Metformin and Rybelsus effectively control blood sugar and reduce A1C levels, which measure your three-month blood sugar average," notes Eapen, MD.

No direct trials compare Rybelsus and metformin alone, but indirect evidence shows semaglutide offers better blood sugar control and weight loss, though with more side effects and higher costs.

Medical guidelines still recommend metformin first, with Rybelsus for patients needing weight loss or unable to tolerate metformin.

Rybelsus for blood sugar control

Clinical studies show consistent results for blood sugar management with Rybelsus. One study found a 1.2% decrease in A1C levels over 6 months (26 weeks).

Metformin for blood sugar control

Metformin is one of the oldest established drugs for blood sugar control (the gold standard). One metformin study found an A1C reduction of 1.1% - 1.2% over 12 months.

Metformin vs Rybelsus: Which one is better for weight loss?

Neither Metformin nor Rybelsus is FDA-approved for weight loss. However, both medications may result in some weight loss when being used for blood sugar control, especially when paired with diet and lifestyle changes.

Semaglutide medications (like Rybelsus) have been shown to reduce food cravings and decrease persistent thoughts about eating. This can help with weight loss, potentially reduce binge eating, and help you stick to a weight loss plan.

Metformin vs Rybelsus: How long do they take to work?

How long does it take for metformin to work?

Metformin can start working immediately. You may notice some improvement fairly quickly, even if full benefits take longer. Research shows that it can start working in a week. However, it may take up to 2 months of consistent use to reach its full effect on blood glucose control.

How long does it take for Rybelsus to work?

Rybelsus lowers blood sugar gradually. During the first month on the 3 mg starter dose, you're just helping your body adjust.

Real benefits may start with the 7 mg or 14 mg doses. Studies show significant A1C improvements after around 26 weeks of treatment (~6 months).

Metformin vs Rybelsus: How long do they stay in your system?

Rybelsus has a long half-life of 7 days. This means that it takes about seven days for the amount in the body to drop by half, and around 5 weeks for it to fully leave the system.

Metformin has a much shorter half-life of 6.2 hours. It should be eliminated from your body in around 4 days.

Metformin vs Rybelsus: Which one has fewer side effects?

Rybelsus commonly causes digestive issues. Nausea, vomiting, stomach pain, abdominal cramping, and diarrhea are common when starting treatment and during dose increases. These usually improve as your body adjusts.

Metformin side effects include diarrhea, nausea, and vomiting. Continuous use of metformin has also been associated with reduced B12 levels.

Both also carry serious but rare risks. Rybelsus has a warning about thyroid C-cell tumors. Let your healthcare provider know if you have a personal or family history of thyroid cancer.

Metformin carries a risk of lactic acidosis, which occurs due to lactate accumulation in the body. Though rare when metformin is taken appropriately, lactic acidosis can be life-threatening.

Metformin vs Rybelsus? Which one is cheaper?

Your actual costs depend on your insurance coverage.

Metformin may be more affordable as there are generic versions available. Being well-studied, with a long history of blood glucose management, it may be more likely to be covered by insurance to treat type 2 diabetes. Brand-name versions of metformin (for example, Glucophage) can be more expensive.

Rybelsus costs approximately $998 per month without insurance. However, if you have commercial insurance and qualify for the manufacturer’s savings programs, you may be able to get Rybelsus for as low as $10.

Please verify with your health plan and healthcare provider about what medication may be best for you and affordable in the long term.

The importance of a diabetes diet

"Medication can help control your blood sugar, but it can't do the job alone. What you eat every day makes a real difference in how well medications like metformin or Rybelsus work for you," explains Rita Faycurry, RD, Registered Dietitian.

Whether you're taking metformin or Rybelsus, your diet will remain a cornerstone of effective diabetes management.

Focus on whole grains, lean proteins, vegetables, and healthy fats while limiting processed foods and added sugars. Consistent meal timing also helps keep blood sugar levels stable throughout the day.

A registered dietitian can create a personalized eating plan tailored to your medication, lifestyle, and health goals. They'll help you understand which foods work best with your treatment.

The good news is that many insurance plans cover dietitian services, especially for medical conditions like type 2 diabetes.

Final thoughts

Metformin and Rybelsus control blood sugar. Metformin offers decades of proven safety, generic pricing, and reliable insurance coverage for type 2 diabetes. Rybelsus, the oral form of semaglutide, provides the added benefit of appetite suppression and reduced food cravings. Though expensive, manufacturer savings programs may lower costs.

Your healthcare provider will choose the best option based on your specific health needs and help monitor your response and manage side effects. Remember that medication is just one part of diabetes management. Diet, exercise, and regular monitoring are equally important for your health.

Frequently asked questions (FAQs)

What are the disadvantages of Rybelsus?

The main disadvantages are cost, specific dosing instructions, and side effects.

At a list price around $1,000 per month without insurance, it's expensive if your insurance does not cover it. You must take it on an empty stomach first thing in the morning with no more than four ounces of plain water and wait 30 minutes before eating or drinking anything. Some people may find this cumbersome. You may also experience digestive side effects with Rybelsus.

Can you take metformin with Rybelsus?

Yes, metformin and Rybelsus are commonly prescribed together for type 2 diabetes when one medication isn't enough. In one small trial, Rybelsus added to metformin helped improve blood sugar control compared to metformin alone. However, any changes to your diabetes medication must be made under a doctor’s supervision.

What's the difference between Rybelsus and metformin?

The main differences are how they work and when you take them. Rybelsus mimics natural hormones to boost insulin production, reduce appetite, and help you feel full. Metformin works differently by reducing how much sugar your liver makes and how much your body absorbs from food.

Rybelsus is oral semaglutide, a newer generation, branded diabetes medication, taken once daily on an empty stomach. Metformin is taken with meals either once or twice daily, depending on the formulation (extended-release or immediate-release), and is available as both branded and affordable generic versions.

Metformin is widely considered the ‘gold standard’ and first-line treatment for newly diagnosed type 2 diabetes. Rybelsus may be chosen when additional blood sugar control is needed.

Find a diabetes dietitian near you, covered by insurance.

The views expressed by authors and contributors of such content are not endorsed or approved by Fay and are intended for informational purposes only. The content is reviewed by Fay only to confirm educational value and audience interest. You are encouraged to discuss any questions that you may have about your health with a healthcare provider.